The Consumer Duty turns one on 31 July 2024, which is the day the first annual Consumer Duty board report on customer outcomes falls due and the day the Duty starts to apply to closed products and services. For investment managers it’s the point at which the Duty moves from an implementation project to business as usual, and the FCA has said it expects firms to be ready. In its 1 March 2024 letter to investment managers it wrote that firms should already have a clear roadmap in place for closed products.
What is the Consumer Duty?
The Consumer Duty is the FCA’s standard requiring firms to act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers. It was set out in PS22/9 in July 2022. It added a Consumer Principle to that effect, along with cross-cutting rules and four outcomes covering products and services, price and value, consumer understanding and consumer support. It came into force on 31 July 2023 for products and services open to sale or renewal, with a further year allowed for closed books.
What counts as a closed product?
The FCA’s definition has two parts: there must be existing customers who took out the product before 31 July 2023, and the product must not have been marketed or distributed, including by renewal, on or after that date. A product that closed to new customers on or after 31 July 2023 isn’t a closed product for this purpose, because it has been under the Duty since last July.
For an investment manager, this could include legacy funds or share classes that stopped being marketed before July 2023 but still have investors. It’s sensible to check each one against the definition rather than assume it qualifies.
What changes for closed products under the Duty?
The FCA’s guidance (FG22/5) says the Duty applies in full to closed products, with one practical difference: because there are no further sales, there’s no need for a target market or distribution strategy. Firms are still expected to:
- Review the product under the cross-cutting rules: check whether any aspect of its design could cause foreseeable harm or stop customers pursuing their financial objectives, and act where it could.
- Make sure it still offers fair value: the price and value outcome applies to closed products, and firms can take account of costs and benefits that have built up over time.
- Meet the understanding and support outcomes: customers in older products still need clear communications and support that works for them.
The guidance suggests starting with an initial review that includes why the product was closed in the first place, since a product that closed because it offered poor value is likely to need particular attention.
When is the first Consumer Duty board report due?
Under PRIN 2A.8, a firm must prepare a report for its board, or equivalent governing body, on the results of its outcome monitoring and the actions needed. At least once a year the board must review and approve that report, confirm whether it’s satisfied the firm is complying with the Duty, and consider whether its future business strategy is consistent with the Duty. When approving the report, the board must also agree actions to address risks and poor outcomes, along with any changes to strategy.
Because the Duty came into force on 31 July 2023, the first report is due by 31 July 2024. A transitional provision means that where a firm has both existing and closed products, this first report need only cover its new and existing products. FG22/5 also says the FCA expects to be provided with the report, and the management information behind it, on request.
What the board report means for investment managers
The board report runs on data, because it needs evidence of outcomes, including whether some groups of customers do worse than others. For a fund range, that means bringing performance, cost, complaints and communications data together, by fund and share class, in a form a board can properly challenge, which is far easier with governed fund data management behind it.
It also sits alongside the assessment of value that authorised fund managers already publish each year. The FCA’s March letter notes that results from those assessments remain variable. It adds that this year it will assess, under the Duty, how investment managers have considered the price and value of what they provide to unit-linked funds, so the two exercises should tell a consistent story.
Closed books need the same rigour as the rest of the range. Legacy share classes often have the oldest data and receive the least attention, so they’ll need the same value and communications review as everything else.
The timeline
- July 2022: PS22/9 and FG22/5 are published
- 31 July 2023: the Duty comes into force for open products and services
- 1 March 2024: the FCA’s letter to investment managers stresses the closed products deadline
- 31 July 2024: the Duty comes into force for closed products and services, and the first annual board report is due
- At least annually from then: the board reviews and approves the outcomes report
What to do now
- Confirm your closed book by testing each legacy fund and share class against the two-part definition and recording the result.
- Finish the value and communications review, checking fair value for closed products and making sure customers in them receive communications they can understand.
- Make the board report evidence-led, basing it on outcome data by product and customer group, with clear actions and owners.
The first year of the Duty was largely about getting ready. From 31 July the focus shifts to showing, with evidence, that customers in every product, whether open or closed, are getting good outcomes.
At Kurtosys we help investment managers keep their fund data governed and consistent, so the same numbers flow into factsheets, regulatory documents, client reports and fund websites. That gives boards and compliance teams one version of performance, costs and communications to assess outcomes against, with an audit trail behind it. If you’d like to talk through how your data supports your Consumer Duty reporting, get in touch.
Sources: FCA PS22/9: a new Consumer Duty, PS22/9 including the PRIN 2A rules (PDF), FCA FG22/5: final guidance for firms on the Consumer Duty, FCA: Consumer Duty information for firms, FCA: asset management and alternatives supervisory strategy, interim update, 1 March 2024, as at 1 July 2024.
About this article
This article reflects the position at 1 July 2024 and was checked against the primary sources available at that time. Thomas Bjerkén, our regulatory reporting and fund data specialist, joined Kurtosys after it was published and now looks after our regulatory content. Some details may have changed since it was published.